Baymahni Exuma: An Honest Review From a Luxury Travel Advisor

There are some places where the water is so ridiculously blue that you wonder if the photos have been edited. Baymahni in Exuma, Bahamas, is one of them. This boutique island escape has beautiful bungalows, stunning beach views, and the kind of setting that makes you want to disconnect and do nothing. On paper, it checks a lot of boxes for a luxury Caribbean getaway.

But as a luxury travel advisor, I look at more than beautiful rooms and pretty beaches. I’m also paying attention to the service, the little details, and whether the overall experience lives up to the price tag. After staying at Baymahni, my take is this: the property itself is stunning, but the service still has some catching up to do. There were plenty of things I loved, along with a few things I’d want my clients to know before booking.

Here’s my honest review of what it’s actually like to stay at Baymahni, and who I think it’s best suited for.

Baymahni Exuma

First Impressions: A Beautiful Setting With a Few Hiccups

Getting to Baymahni is part of the experience. From Exuma International Airport, it’s about a 20 minute drive to the Exuma Yacht Club dock, where the resort’s water taxi takes you across to the property.

Before our arrival, the concierge contacted me approximately five times to coordinate our taxi. I appreciated the communication and felt cautiously optimistic everything was arranged. However upon arrival, the taxi service had been double booked, so two vehicles showed up instead of one. Not a huge deal, but an unnecessary mix up considering how many times we’d communicated about the arrangements.

I also noticed that the price quoted by the concierge for our arrival taxi didn’t match what we were ultimately charged. Again, not a huge deal, but not the most seamless arrival experience.

One nice touch: our drivers allowed us to stop at the grocery store and liquor store along the way. More on that later, because it can be a useful way to manage the cost of your stay.

Once we reached the dock, we boarded Baymahni’s water taxi for the boat ride to the resort. This part really is beautiful. Depending on the time of year, the bay can be wonderfully calm or busy with boat traffic, but the turquoise water makes for a memorable introduction to the island.

Upon arrival, two staff members greeted us, collected our luggage, and escorted us to reception. The reception area has minimal air conditioning, so it was a warm and humid start. On the other hand, the team surprised us with welcome drinks themed around our group, which I’d arranged in advance. That was a thoughtful touch.

My first impression? The setting was every bit as beautiful as I’d hoped, and there were some nice personal touches. The logistics, however, weren’t quite as seamless as I’d expect from a luxury property.

The Bungalows: 

I stayed as part of a girls trip, so we had two two-bedroom bungalows, one on the lagoon side and one on the beach side. Both had stunning views, and I could see the appeal of each location.

The lagoon side bungalows are closer to the water taxi dock, while the beach side bungalows put you closer to the beach restaurant, bar and the main beach where the water toys are kept. Personally, I wouldn’t automatically pay a significant premium for one location over the other. The price difference varies depending on your dates and the bungalow categories available. Sometimes it’s minimal; other times, it’s considerably more.

Based on my experience, I don’t think the difference alone justifies paying more than a couple hundred dollars extra per night more for the beach location. Both are beautiful, so I’d compare the actual rates for your dates and decide which location benefits you value the most. 

What to Know About the Two Bedroom Bungalows

I can see these bungalows working well for a small family or two couples traveling together. Each has two king bed bedrooms, along with a small bunk bed in the upper lofts. One caveat for families: those loft bunks are tight. I’d consider them suitable for younger children, but I wouldn’t plan on teenagers sleeping there comfortably.

The bathrooms also vary. Some bungalows have a double sink vanity, while others have a single sink. If you’re traveling as a couple, I’d select a cottage with the double sink configuration.

And here’s another detail worth knowing before you book: all the bungalows have outdoor showers, with no indoor shower. If that’s not your thing, it’s better to know before you arrive. The rooms come with the usual amenities, including coffee, tea, robes, and a beach bag. The hair dryers were fantastic, but I did miss having a full length mirror. Getting a proper outfit check before dinner was a bit of a challenge!

Overall, I thought the bungalows were one of the strongest parts of the stay. They’re beautiful, and the views really do deliver.

The Beach Is the Star of the Show

If you’re coming to Exuma for that impossibly blue water, Baymahni won’t disappoint. The beach and surrounding scenery are absolutely gorgeous. It’s the kind of place where you can spend hours enjoying the water without needing to do much of anything else. 

The resort has non motorized water toys available, including floats, kayaks, and paddle boards. So unless you have a favorite float you can’t live without, save the suitcase space and leave yours at home.

The main beach is also near the beach restaurant and bar, making it easy to grab a drink or something to eat without wandering far from your spot by the water. For me, the setting is a big part of Baymahni’s appeal. If your ideal vacation involves beautiful beaches, time on the water, and a more laid back island atmosphere, this is where the resort really shines.

Dining: Good Food, Great Views, and a Budget to Consider

Baymahni has two on-property restaurants: The Beacon, a traditional sit down à la carte restaurant, and the Beach Bar Restaurant, which has incredible views of the beach. I thought the food was pretty good overall. Most dishes were around an 8 out of 10 for me, give or take depending on what we ordered. I was generally happy with our meals, although I wouldn’t choose the resort specifically for a culinary experience.

One thing I’d factor into your budget is the cost of food and beverages. Dining and drinks on the property can get expensive, especially if you’re staying for several nights. With only two restaurants onsite, you’ll probably want to explore some nearby dining options for a change of scenery.

Dining Beyond the Resort

We ate at Snappy Turtle, a very casual restaurant that offered good food at a more economical price point. We had great service during our visit, although it’s worth noting that we were the only guests in the restaurant at the time. If you’re looking for a laid-back meal without the resort price tag, it’s worth considering.

We also heard about a new floating restaurant nearby that the water taxi could take us to. Unfortunately, between the weather and our schedule, we didn’t get the chance to check it out. It’s an option I’d be interested in exploring on a future visit, but I’d confirm that it’s operating before making plans.

Another spot to know about is Chat ‘N’ Chill, a well known beach shack style bar and restaurant just around the corner from Baymahni on Stocking Island. Unfortunately, it was closed during our visit. Typically, it’s known for casual food and drinks, along with a conch shack where you can purchase raw conch to feed the stingrays that swim through the area. If it’s open during your stay, it could be a fun change of scenery from dining at the resort.

Important Things to Know: Weather, Water Taxis, and Restaurant Hours

This is something I’d really want travelers to understand before booking Baymahni. Because of its private island location, your ability to venture off property depends on more than just having a restaurant or activity in mind. If heavy rain is in the forecast, be prepared to stay at the resort. Water taxi service can shut down in poor weather, and restaurants around the bay may also close, leaving you with only the two on property dining options. Over a stay of several nights, meals can start to feel repetitive pretty quickly.

There’s another catch: restaurants in the area may close without notice, particularly when business is slow. Don’t assume a restaurant is open just because Google or its website says it is. Always call ahead, or ask the Baymahni reception desk to call and confirm before heading out. The last thing you want is to coordinate transportation to a restaurant only to discover it’s closed when you arrive.

You’ll also want to plan your timing carefully. The water taxi can’t access all the waterfront restaurants after dark, so expect to visit these spots for an early dinner rather than a late night outing. Confirm the return transportation arrangements before you leave the resort, especially if you’re dining somewhere farther away.

These logistics aren’t necessarily a reason to avoid Baymahni, but they’re important to understand when planning your stay. I’d keep an eye on the forecast, avoid building your itinerary too tightly around off property dining, and have some flexibility in your plans.

My Tip for Keeping Food Costs in Check

I’d take advantage of the grocery and liquor store stop on the way to the dock. Picking up favorite snacks, breakfast essentials, or beverages can be helpful rather than purchasing everything at resort prices.

It’s also nice to have a few things available in your bungalow if the weather keeps you from venturing out or you simply want a more casual option.

Where the Luxury Experience Fell Short

This is the part I think is important to share, particularly if you’re considering Baymahni for a special occasion or expecting a highly polished luxury experience. Everyone we encountered was very nice and helpful. My concerns weren’t about friendliness or willingness to assist. They were about the lack of anticipation and coordination.

In my experience, luxury service is about more than responding when a guest asks for something. It’s about noticing the little things and making the experience feel effortless. At Baymahni, the service felt more reactive than anticipatory. For example, I took my coffee cup out of our bungalow each morning to enjoy my coffee on the beach. Housekeeping never replaced the cups, so I had to ask for new ones. Sure, it’s a small thing. But it’s also the kind of detail that separates a pleasant stay from one where you feel genuinely taken care of.

The bigger frustration came on departure day. Our water taxi had been scheduled, but no bellman had been arranged to collect our luggage from the bungalow. At 6 a.m., I sent the resort a WhatsApp message asking for assistance. No one responded, apart from the boat captain. We ended up carrying our own luggage down the stairs and through the resort’s rocky pathways to the water taxi. Again, the issue wasn’t that anyone was rude. It was that the coordination simply wasn’t there. For a property positioned as a luxury escape, I’d expect the team to connect the dots between a scheduled departure, luggage assistance, and getting guests to the dock without having to manage those details themselves.

My takeaway: Baymahni has the setting and accommodations to deliver a wonderful luxury vacation, but the service experience wasn’t consistently at that same level during my stay. I’d like to see more proactive communication, better coordination, and greater attention to the small details.

Baymahni Bahamas

A Few Things I’d Want You to Know Before Booking

Beyond the room and service considerations, there are a few practical details that could make a difference in your stay.

Boat excursions likely require extra transportation.

Being on a private island doesn’t mean every excursion operator can pick you up directly at the resort. Depending on where your tour departs, you may need to take Baymahni’s water taxi to the Exuma Yacht Club dock, arrange a car taxi to another part of Great Exuma, and depart from a different marina or beach. Before booking an excursion, be aware of the departure location and transportation arrangements. An activity that looks simple on paper may involve several separate transfers, so I would get the logistics sorted out in advance.

Get the reception desk’s WhatsApp number.

Having the number makes it easier to request the water taxi, ask for something to be brought to your room, or get assistance during your stay. Just don’t assume every message will receive an immediate response.

Don’t rely solely on restaurant opening hours.

Restaurants on and off the property may close without notice if business is slow. Ask the front desk to call ahead and confirm before heading out.

Leave the heels at home.

Some pathways around the resort are rocky and uneven. Flat sandals or comfortable slides will be much more practical.

So, Would I Recommend Baymahni?

Yes, for the right traveler, with the right expectations. Baymahni is undeniably gorgeous! The bungalows are lovely, the beach is spectacular, and the surrounding water is everything you’d hope for in an Exuma escape. If you’re looking for a boutique island setting where you can spend your days enjoying the beach and slowing down, there’s plenty to love.

Where I’d manage expectations is the service. Based on my stay, I wouldn’t put Baymahni in the category of a fully polished, anticipatory luxury experience just yet. The team was friendly, but the coordination and attention to detail didn’t always match the property itself. I’d also pay close attention to the bungalow pricing, sleeping arrangements, dining budget, and transportation logistics before booking. Baymahni truly has a lot going for it. It’s just important that travelers can manage expectations so they can decide whether it’s the right fit.

Considering Baymahni for your next Bahamas getaway? J.Upton Travel can help you weigh the pros and cons, compare the available accommodations, and determine whether this property fits the kind of vacation you want.

Start Your Custom Trip Inquiry Here

FAQs

1. Is Baymahni Exuma worth it? Baymahni is worth considering if you prioritize beautiful beaches, stunning turquoise water, and a boutique island atmosphere. However, based on my experience, the service and logistics aren’t quite at the level I’d expect from a fully polished luxury resort, so it’s important to weigh the beautiful setting against your expectations for service.

2. Is Baymahni good for families? Yes, Baymahni’s two bedroom bungalows can be a good option for small families. Each bedroom has a king bed, with additional bunk beds in the loft that are best suited for younger children. Keep in mind that all bungalows have outdoor showers rather than indoor showers.

3. Are there restaurants outside of Baymahni? Yes, there are dining options nearby, including casual restaurants such as Snappy Turtle and Chat ‘N’ Chill when open. However, restaurant hours can change without notice, water taxi service may be limited by weather or after dark, and some restaurants require additional transportation. Always confirm operating hours and transportation arrangements before heading out.

4. What should I know before booking Baymahni? Compare bungalow prices carefully, as the cost difference between lagoon side and beach side accommodations can vary significantly. Budget for relatively expensive on property dining, consider stocking up on essentials before arrival, confirm transfer costs, and plan excursions and off property dining around water taxi availability and weather conditions.

Interested in learning about other hotels in the Bahamas? Check out our article on the Baha Mar Hotel options.

Meet the Blogger

Hi, I’m Jessica

I’m the founder of J.Upton Travel. Growing up in small-town Texas, I didn’t travel much—until my husband’s job in luxury hotels opened the door to incredible experiences. From planning our destination wedding in Mexico to exploring Thailand and Italy, I fell in love with curating unforgettable trips. After working in a luxury travel agency, I launched J.Upton Travel in 2017 to help others explore the world with ease and elegance.

Leave A Comment

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Scroll to Top
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x